Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Families: Mom v. Dad

           My interviewee was my mom. She was born in Mexico and reestablished life in the U.S. when she was two years old. My mom’s upbringing was based on Catholic ideals and was taught at a very young age to always act responsibly and be self-sufficient. My mom has always been an independent individual and by age eight, she was helping my grandmother with the cooking and cleaning. Growing up, she was a bit of a tomboy, due to being raised with four brothers. She has one sister, but my aunt married very young so my mom was left with just her parents and four brothers. Due to some hardships that my mom experienced growing up and as a young adult, she is a very strong and motivated woman.
           Throughout the interview, I was very comfortable asking my mom questions about family members. My mom is my best friend so I can literally talk about to her about everything and anything. We have a very close bond and we talk multiple times on a daily basis. This being said, I know a lot of my mom’s extended family, if not by face then by name. There was no awkwardness, but there were some silent moments because my mom did not remember several of her cousins’ names because quite honestly she has so many cousins from both sides of my grandparents’ family. I do not think this affected my thoroughness of my interview.  Had I not been interviewing my mom, I do not think it would be awkward because I am able to adapt to people’s personality. I do not mind asking questions, but I also try not to step over any boundaries. Sometimes it is difficult trying not to not cross the line between informative and too personal.
            My mom is definitely closer to my grandmother’s side of the family. She was able to remember specific details regarding certain aunts/uncles and she seemed happy talking about it. She said that they visited my grandmother’s siblings more often than my grandpa’s siblings. My mom is very close to my grandma so I think that might have an impact on how my mom views her family from my grandma’s side versus her views of her family from my grandpa’s side of the family. Regardless, my mom has a lot of respect for her elders, especially her grandparents from both parents. Her grandmother (dad’s mom) would stay often with my mom and her siblings, but whenever she would visit in Mexico, she would stay with my grandma’s parents. She even called her grandparents (mom’s parents) Ama Margarita and Pa Angel. Her parents were okay with this because they had a lot of respect for their own parents and they understood the close bond they had. Both families had large families. They also shared names. My mom’s middle name is Elena and she has a least five cousins with the same name and another three that share her first name. Both my grandparents’ families know each other well and socialize from time to time. They are respectful to one another and when around one another they greet each other well. Overall, I think my mom is closer to my grandmother’s family because they were around more often than my grandfather’s family.

            I know more relatives from my mom’s side of the family. My dad has a really big family so I do not know them all, but besides that, I have always felt more comfortable with my mom’s family. They are always so welcoming and friendly while my dad’s family always takes a while to warm up to us and sometimes a certain aunt has this major attitude and it makes things awkward. My brothers and I were raised to always respect our elders so it makes it difficult to deal with her. We socialize more with my mom’s side of the family because my mom and grandmother (dad’s mom) do not have the best relationship and so my mom does not really like to spend time with my dad’s family.  My mom has never told us to stay away from my grandmother or the entire family, but their actions is what pushes us away and not desire to spend time with them. The women overall seem to take charge in my family. I know that in my home, my mom makes the important decisions. She discusses everything with my dad, but ultimately she has the last say so. My grandmother is the same way. The relatives that marry into the family are not treated any differently than those born into the family from my mom’s side.  They believe in being treated equally and unless you show otherwise, you will have the love and respect you deserve. On my dad’s side however, it is the total opposite. The relatives that marry into the family are seen as outsiders no matter the years of knowing one another or actions. There are no different attitudes based on gender. On both sides of our families there are gay and transgender relatives that are not mistreated. It did take some getting used to at first for some relatives, but they were never mistreated or discriminated against. Through this exercise I have learned that I am very close to my immediate family; parents and siblings. I know a lot about my mom’s side of the family and I also share a great bond with my grandparents (mom’s parents). The women in my family seem to ‘wear the pants’ and the men seem to be okay with this concept.  

6 comments:

  1. Very good introduction to your mother.

    "I do not think this affected my thoroughness of my interview. Had I not been interviewing my mom, I do not think it would be awkward because I am able to adapt to people’s personality. I do not mind asking questions, but I also try not to step over any boundaries. Sometimes it is difficult trying not to not cross the line between informative and too personal. "

    You might have a future in anthropology! :-) Yes, part of the skill needed in these interviews is knowing when not to cross the line, but honestly, sometimes the line needs to be crossed. That boundary is something we create based upon our own beliefs and experiences. The line is going to be different for our interviewees. You might be surprised how much they are willing to discuss if they are treated respectfully and some are happy to have someone so interested in their lives, making them thrilled to open up and talk.

    I love how you described how you refer to each of your relatives. This is often very telling in a kinship discussion and I may have to include this in future assignments. Good job. Names tell a great story about a family and its interrelationships.

    Sounds like there is an emphasis on women's power in your family, though that doesn't rule out that your family tends toward patrilineal descent. This is actually common in Catholic-based Hispanic populations. Before Catholicism was adopted, matrilineal patterns were stronger in Hispanic cultures. The introduction of Catholic beliefs brought with it the patrilineal emphasis from the church, but didn't completely wipe out the importance of the women in the family.

    Good discussion throughout. Well done.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Cristina,
    I loved reading your kinship interview. I notice that we had similarities with our subjects (we both used our mothers) and that or mothers seem to be closer to our grandmothers side of the family. I also noticed that you say the women in your family "wear the pants" as opposed to mine that is usually male dominated. Differences make this assignment and life in general very interesting and thoroughly enjoyed learning about your family.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Christina,
    Great interview on your mother. I think that interviewing immediate family members is such a comforting thing. It feels like you are sitting back and reminiscing about the past. I interviewed my dad and he told me many stories as a side note as he was growing up. It really makes you feel like you are getting to know your parents even more. I also see that, just like my family, many hispanic families grew up with Catholic ideals and morals that followed them into their adulthood. I really enjoyed reading your blog post about your mother she sounds like a magnificent person.

    Marlon

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello!
    I loved reading your blog post- in fact it reminded me of my own family simply because my family is from Mexico as well and when I asked my mom about her cousins she also said that she has way too many- I have 13! Your interview was very informative and I really liked the introduction to your mom :) Your mom sounds lovely! Have a great week :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Cristina! Great blog post! It was nice getting to know your mother through your interview. :)
    One similarity I think we had in the interview process was imagining interviewing someone outside of our own family (maybe someone we don't know at all). I, too, felt like I wouldn't know where the line between informative and personal is. What I found throughout the interview is, a lot of the time, the things that were tougher and more personal revealed a lot more about my mom's family in comparison to the straight-forward, objective things. (Not that there's no value in the straight-forward...but listening to my mom dig a little deeper about her family history revealed a lot!) Maybe anthropologists just need to respectfully cross that line in order to get the information they need.

    ReplyDelete